US Proposes Ending Deference to Prior Approvals — Work Visa Extensions Face Fresh Scrutiny

The United States Department of Homeland Security (DHS) has proposed removing the regulation that tells US Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) to give weight to its own previous approvals when deciding work visa extensions. The proposed rule, published in the Federal Register on 14 October 2026, would delete the “deference” provision at 8 CFR 214.1(c)(5). If it is finalised, officers deciding extension petitions on Form I-129 — the form behind H-1B, L-1, O-1, TN, E and several other work categories — would assess each request on its own evidence, even where the same employer, worker and job were approved before. Nothing has changed yet: this is a proposal, the current rule remains in force, and public comments are open until 13 November 2026.

What happened

Deference is the reason an unchanged extension is usually the least dramatic filing in US work immigration. Under the current regulation — written into the rules in December 2024 as part of the H-1B modernization rule — when USCIS adjudicates an extension involving the same parties and the same underlying facts, it defers to its earlier determination of eligibility, unless there was a material error in that decision, a material change in circumstances, or new material information that counts against eligibility. The proposal would remove that instruction entirely. DHS’s stated reason is legal: the immigration statute places the burden of proving eligibility on the petitioner, applicant or beneficiary, and the department says deference sits uneasily with that burden and can let earlier errors carry forward into later decisions.

The practical effects are set out in DHS’s own estimates, as reported by immigration law firm NPZ Law Group and others: about 208,000 Form I-129 petitions a year — roughly 30 percent of filings — are currently eligible for deference, and the department projects around 6,044 additional requests for evidence (RFEs) a year if the rule takes effect, with cases that draw an RFE taking substantially longer to decide. The policy has swung with administrations before: introduced as guidance in 2004, withdrawn in 2017, restored in 2021 and codified in 2024. This proposal would remove the codified version.

Who this affects

Workers already in the USA on employer-sponsored visas

Anyone whose job runs on an I-129 petition — H-1B professionals, L-1 transferees, O-1 workers, TN professionals and E treaty workers among them — is extended through this process, typically every few years. Under deference, an extension with unchanged facts starts from a position of strength: the earlier approval counts. If the proposal is finalised, each extension becomes a fuller re-examination, so expect employers to document the role, the worksite and the worker’s qualifications as thoroughly as for a first filing, and expect more RFEs along the way. Because dependants’ applications (Form I-539) are filed alongside these petitions, delays would ripple through to families as well.

Employers and sponsors

The burden of proof sits with petitioners, and DHS itself projects more RFEs and longer adjudications. For employers that means earlier filing, thicker evidence files and more contingency planning around start dates, project timelines and travel while an extension is pending.

People still outside the USA

The proposal does not change initial petitions, the H-1B cap registration process or consular visa applications — if you are seeking a first US work visa, this rule is not about you. It matters indirectly: how predictable extensions are forms part of how employers judge the cost of sponsoring, and part of how candidates judge an offer that is meant to last beyond a single visa period.

What job seekers should do now

  1. Do not treat the proposal as law. The current deference regulation remains in force. DHS must consider the comments submitted by 13 November 2026 and publish a final rule before anything changes, and a final rule could differ from the proposal.
  2. If your extension falls due in the next year or so, prepare like a first filing. Keep the evidence that proved eligibility the first time — degree and credential evaluations, employer support letters, worksite and job-duty details — current and complete, so your employer is not rebuilding the file from scratch if scrutiny rises.
  3. Employers and workers can comment. The Federal Register docket (USCIS-2026-0529) is open for public comment until 13 November 2026, and comments from affected employers and professional bodies are exactly what DHS is required to weigh before finalising.
  4. Keep your wider search moving. Your extension is your employer’s process; your career options are yours. Browse current openings on our Jobs in USA page, or search every vacancy on the Find Jobs page — and read the route summaries on our USA Visa & Immigration page before building a move around a single petition.

Why a one-paragraph rule matters

Deference never guaranteed approval. What it guaranteed was that an approval, once earned on unchanged facts, would not be re-argued without a reason. Removing it does not make any individual extension fail; it makes every extension less predictable — and predictability is what multi-year hiring plans, project staffing and family decisions are built on. The projected numbers look modest at system level, some 6,044 extra RFEs a year across roughly 208,000 deference-eligible petitions. But for the individual worker whose case draws an RFE, the extra weeks or months land on a real job, a real lease and a real family’s status. That is why a one-paragraph regulatory deletion is worth watching if your working life runs on an I-129.

Frequently asked questions

Is the deference rule already gone?

No. It remains in force. The 14 October publication is a proposal; DHS must consider public comments — open until 13 November 2026 — and issue a final rule before anything changes.

Which visas does this cover?

Petitions filed on Form I-129. Reporting on the proposal lists the H-1B, L-1, O-1, E-1, E-2, E-3, H-2A, H-2B, H-3, P, Q, R and TN classifications; dependants apply on Form I-539.

Would a past approval count for nothing?

Not even under the proposal. Officers could still look at a case’s history; what would change is that they would no longer be directed to defer to the earlier decision. Each extension would stand or fall on the evidence in front of them.

When could a final rule take effect?

No date has been set. DHS first has to review the comments it receives; watch the Federal Register docket (USCIS-2026-0529) for the final rule, if one is issued.


Sources: The Financial Express, “Trump targets H-1B visa extensions: Why past approvals may no longer help”, published October 2026: https://www.financialexpress.com/immigration/trump-targets-h-1b-visa-extensions-why-past-approvals-may-no-longer-help/4360719/ — NPZ Law Group, “USCIS Deference to Prior Approvals May End: What the October 14 Proposal Means for H-1B, L-1, and O-1 Extensions”, updated 22 October 2026: https://visaserve.com/uscis-deference-to-prior-approvals-may-end-what-the-october-14-proposal-means-for-h-1b-l-1-and-o-1-extensions — Edex Live, “US proposes changes to H-1B visa extensions: Impact on Indians”, published October 2026: https://www.edexlive.com/news/us-proposes-ending-deference-to-previous-h-1b-approvals-what-it-means-for-indians

AlfaCareers is an international job board connecting candidates with employers hiring in the USA, Canada, the UK, Australia, the UAE, Saudi Arabia and beyond. Employers can post jobs through paid packages; candidates always apply free.

Leave a Comment